[SC] - Commissioning Research through the Messari Hub

In an effort to scale the amount of quality, long-form research available, we are proposing API3 to utilize their existing membership on the Messari Hub - a community-driven marketplace that allocates funds to top independent analysts, to commission various value-add research reports. This would serve to better inform the crypto ecosystem on major developments and ongoing fundamental changes, effectively attracting more builders, investors, and users to provide value to API3.

Rationale:

Currently, there is a high barrier for those within existing project communities and the broader crypto ecosystem to stay informed and up to date with all of the major fundamental and protocol-level changes. While there are various analytics dashboards, blog posts, and messaging channels to stay informed, it is still cumbersome to have a strong understanding of all the important happenings going on. This leads to a misallocation of resources, both time and money, since the community is not acting with the full breadth of knowledge at their disposal.

To alleviate this problem, many of the largest DAOs are expending additional resources to better surface a lot of this core information (Example: Yearn quarterly reports). These initiatives are serving to increasingly professionalize this industry and soon will be necessary for a project to be viewed as legitimate. However, what is still missing is the proper contextualization of this data from an independent third party that would allow an outsider to gain better insight into what’s going on.

Abstract:

You can think about the Hub like a research specific Grant program. Projects can determine a set budget to go towards better informing existing and prospective stakeholders through quality research. Messari is then able to effectively allocate that budget through our network of top performing analysts. Examples include:

  • Rasheed Saleuddin PhD, CFA
    • Research Associate at Cambridge Centre for Alternative Finance
    • Example reports: Mirror v2, yAxis
  • Francois-Xavier Lord
  • Tesa Ho
    • Head of Trading, Uphold, Inc.
    • Example Report: Understanding MEV (paywalled, available on request)
  • Karim Halabi
    • Business Development, Chainalysis
    • Example Report: Ocean protocol (paywalled, available on request)

Messari works closely with Hub analysts to ensure reports are comprehensive and objectively written. Commissioned reports live as free reports on our site and are also sent out through our newsletter (120k subscribers) and various social channels to a wide audience of active crypto participants.

Proposal:

We are proposing a $100k grant to fund the following reports:

  • Initiation of coverage report that takes a deep dive into API3, its background, the problem it’s looking to solve, token mechanics and various design tradeoffs compared to other oracle providers out there.

  • 4 quarterly reports that present and analyze major KPIs and fundamental metrics (projects using API3, number of calls), governance developments, upgrades, and key roadmap initiatives. [We recently received a grant from the Compound Grants program for a set of these over the next year with the first to be released shortly that we can share as an example.]

  • An additional report on a topic of the community’s choosing that could cover any topic such as the implications of a major upgrade or highlighting major partnerships and how it impacts the project more broadly

We are very open to any and all feedback and are excited to work more closely with the API3 community!

6 Likes

Thanks for the post @jpurd17!
I’d be heavily in favour of this and think you guys are doing an incredible job at messari in regards to educational material! We talked about a lot of this stuff back at ETHcc in Paris so I’m glad to see some of it come to fruition!

Questions I had were:

  • Would the reports be market as e.g. API3 commissioned similar to the Mirror report that is commissioned by Terra?
  • How would you determine the community chosen topic of deep dive?
  • if I understand correctly, we’re looking at 6 total reports? One deep dive, quarterly reports for a year highlighting how the project evolved and a final topic of our choosing?
4 Likes

100% needed.

A lot of serious industry insiders and projects read Messari reports as their go-to-source.

Honestly, i think this will be one of the most effective marketing/educational spend $ we’ve seen to date (targeted for retail audience). Given that API3 is mainly a B2B project, we need to do more to educate the general public with API3.

2 Likes

I am in favour of this. I’d be most interested in a report that looks at how the tokenomics are (theoretically) outlined in the whitepaper, and how they’ve practically been playing out so far.

3 Likes

Also, very much in favour. Objective real-time analytics showing network utility / eco-system activity is paramout.

1 Like

Thanks for the support and feedback! To answer your questions @UgurMersin

  • Yes, the report would have similar language mentioning it was commissioned by API3 likely with a note that it was done through decentralized governance
  • I was thinking once a quarter soliciting feedback from the community via discord on if the timing is right and if there is a specific topic in mind. If so, Messari will then put together a report scope on how we see the outline looking that we can propose and through a simple yes/no poll can move forward with a majority
  • Correct!
3 Likes

Thanks for the answers! Like i mentioned before, i am deeply in favor of this.
We’d possibly have to see how we deal with the voting part, since everybody can join the forum and vote on a poll, but it wouldnt be a representation of the actual voting power.

1 Like

Assuming that some of the projects that had this done have some budget transparency, how much did they pay?

4 Likes