To few voters/votes

Currently there are 5 proposals which will all pass. - 3.8.2021 21:00 UTC
There were only 35 votes from 19 different wallets at this point.

Burak has about 16% voting power, think he got most by delegation.

Any suggestions from the team on how to make this more decentralized?

What do you think about rewarding the voters?
Everything is publicly viewable.
https://etherscan.io/txs?a=0x1c8058e72e4902b3431ef057e8d9a58a73f26372

Here the list of voters.
marco99.eth
erichdylus.eth
dav3.eth
creampp.eth
bbenligiray.eth
0xfe2e4d5957e3c3b5bcf8aa54335fe00c15741cd2
0xf6092c8af9f00a7d611f0a437997a98e28215c3b
0xe346b544fe25ba829bc0d799f653116f49b35330
0xe0d6480ae69e7c4928a3f45e6cf5651e52741ec0
0xdd1dfb33ea386b6380ba6f47b06182130541934c
0xcdb49b0be40e3605a098e5c97005910cc9f2106a
0xb09d71046337859ac165b8628606bf6b51fbed18
0xa2c205c11071051d2556130a7165b6256eb6601f
0xa1cb671857a9bae25dbbb0e71998e1192e09af1c
0x5006a6aace95f09489d56d3017d117b0755819d7
0x3146f17d9bef9dadd00e61c87cabe6f9bef79b2a
0x22ed76b412a6fae0de4bf660f5f811d7bd48a12a
0x1ed4800a62fbe3a4dc09d32a800ed43bd87b5d20
0x11903651bf07ed6a5fc5e39cefed810187717d4e

Personally i wouldn’t read too much into a) secondary proposals and b) ones that come from known parties.
The general voting outcome is similar to what i have seen in other governance/voting situations. The current decision is not big enough to attract a significant movement from all the parties that are able to vote. It’s previous grantees asking for grants again.

Incentivizing voting at this stage will just lead to all people voting how the majority is voting because they get a share or a voting reward. I’d even say that in most cases its more hurtful than anything, because you’re forcing people into a decision that they do not have the drive to make themselves, so whatever they decide on will not “magically” be thought out now that you give them something in return.

6 Likes

In addition to Ugur’s points, I’d also emphasize that funding grants to those intimately involved with the project with ongoing tasks are likely to be less controversial than new initiatives and thus solicit fewer “against” votes, and secondary proposals’ quora are easier to meet, thus dis-incentivizing unnecessary additional “for” votes so the numbers aren’t too surprising so far.

Delegation is not to be taken lightly, so I do encourage (especially identified, whether individual or pseudo-anon) addresses to have a delegation pitch and disclosure - I’m happy to help with these.

3 Likes

Thanks Ugur and Erich for your answers. Have looked at other governance, is similar there. I have also paid too little attention to the delegation.

I see your points and agree.

Am curious to participation when it comes to subDAO proposal or using the primary agent. Think that the high fees have also kept many away. (which will change in the future)